The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

AP story section

August 8, 2013

U.S. judge orders EEOC to pay $4.7M legal bill

Associated Press

IOWA CITY — A judge has ordered the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission to pay an Iowa trucking company $4.7 million in legal costs for bringing what she called dozens of “unreasonable or groundless” claims of sexual harassment during a lawsuit that’s lasted six years.

U.S. District Judge Linda Reade’s judgment for CRST Van Expedited, entered last week, is believed to be the largest-ever fee sanction against the EEOC, according to employment attorneys and the agency itself.

“We’re deeply disappointed in the decision and we’re definitely considering next steps, which may include appealing,” EEOC spokeswoman Christine Nazer said Tuesday. She added, “We’ve got folks who have been here a long time and nobody can recall fees higher than this.”

The case began with a 2005 complaint from Monika Starke, an Azle, Texas, driver who alleged that she was paired with a male colleague who constantly made crude sexual remarks and advances. After failing to reach a settlement, the EEOC filed a class-action lawsuit in 2007 on behalf of female CRST drivers who it said were subjected to offensive comments, groped or even assaulted by male trainers and co-drivers during cross-country trips.

After the lawsuit was filed, EEOC eventually said it was bringing claims on behalf of 270 women and alleged CRST had a practice of tolerating harassment. The company disputed the allegations, saying that it had internal procedures for reporting, investigating and taking action to stop harassment.

Reade eventually dismissed all the claims on a variety of legal grounds, including the statute of limitations and EEOC’s failure to have some of the women deposed by a court deadline. In 2010, she ordered the EEOC to pay $4.5 million in legal costs, blasting it for a “sue first, ask questions later” litigation strategy.

The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the fee award last year and reinstated Starke’s claim, but largely upheld Reade’s other rulings, agreeing that EEOC must investigate the claims of every potential victim and seek informal settlements before filing class-action lawsuits. The agency says the standard has made it harder to pursue similar class-action cases in the 8th Circuit, which spans from North Dakota to Arkansas.

Text Only
AP story section
  • State to reopen Juvenile Home DES MOINES -- A district court judge on Wednesday ordered the state to reopen the Iowa Juvenile Home, telling Gov. Terry Branstad he cannot unilaterally change a law approved by the state Legislature. Judge Scott Rosenberg said the home in Toledo was

    February 6, 2014

  • Panel OKs ban on remote abortion pill distribution DES MOINES -- A legislative panel approved a measure Wednesday that would ban the remote distribution of abortion pills, a proposal the bill's sponsor said is intended to delay the procedure and give women more time to change their minds. The subcomm

    February 6, 2014

  • Sioux City gambling group halts local grants SIOUX CITY -- The nonprofit that holds the gambling license for the Argosy Sioux City riverboat casino has voted to temporarily stop sending grants to local charities and government agencies. A legal dispute with the operator of the casino, Penn Nati

    January 15, 2014

  • Davenport pays, apologizes to hearing impaired man DAVENPORT (AP) -- The city of Davenport has issued an unusual apology to a former alderman after a police employee was caught on tape saying that he intentionally knocked softly on the hearing-impaired man's door when responding to a service call. Th

    January 15, 2014

  • Budget Branstad presents budget for next fiscal year DES MOINES -- Gov. Terry Branstad offered a budget proposal Tuesday that includes a tax break for veterans, a tuition freeze for college students and incentives to encourage Internet expansion in rural Iowa, a more modest list of priorities one year

    January 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Gov. restores more felons' voting rights IOWA CITY (AP) -- Gov. Terry Branstad restored voting rights to more felons in 2013 than the prior two years combined, but thousands of others remain disenfranchised under a 2011 policy change. Data released by the governor's office to The Associated

    January 15, 2014

  • Man fatally shot at Fla. theater over texting WESLEY CHAPEL, Fla. (AP) -- A 71-year-old retired police officer accused of shooting a man dead in a Florida movie theater told authorities that "he was in fear of being attacked" during Monday's confrontation. Curtis Reeves is charged with second-de

    January 15, 2014

  • Iowa Senator: Congress must confirm election board DES MOINES -- An Iowa senator asked a U.S. Senate committee Wednesday to confirm appointees to a federal election commission so a decision can be made about whether Iowa Secretary of State Matt Schultz is properly using money for voter-fraud investig

    January 9, 2014

  • School Discipline Gov't: End overly zealous discipline in schools WASHINGTON, D.C. -- The Obama administration is urging schools to abandon overly zealous discipline policies that civil rights advocates have long said lead to a school-to-prison pipeline that discriminates against minority students. The wide-ranging

    January 9, 2014 1 Photo

  • Governor, lawmakers set modest goals for 2014 DES MOINES -- After reaching bipartisan agreements on several major policy initiatives last year, Gov. Terry Branstad said Wednesday that he is setting more modest expectations for the 2014 legislative session. Speaking at The Associated Press' annua

    January 9, 2014

AP Video
National News