The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

AP story section

August 8, 2013

U.S. judge orders EEOC to pay $4.7M legal bill

Associated Press

IOWA CITY — A judge has ordered the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission to pay an Iowa trucking company $4.7 million in legal costs for bringing what she called dozens of “unreasonable or groundless” claims of sexual harassment during a lawsuit that’s lasted six years.

U.S. District Judge Linda Reade’s judgment for CRST Van Expedited, entered last week, is believed to be the largest-ever fee sanction against the EEOC, according to employment attorneys and the agency itself.

“We’re deeply disappointed in the decision and we’re definitely considering next steps, which may include appealing,” EEOC spokeswoman Christine Nazer said Tuesday. She added, “We’ve got folks who have been here a long time and nobody can recall fees higher than this.”

The case began with a 2005 complaint from Monika Starke, an Azle, Texas, driver who alleged that she was paired with a male colleague who constantly made crude sexual remarks and advances. After failing to reach a settlement, the EEOC filed a class-action lawsuit in 2007 on behalf of female CRST drivers who it said were subjected to offensive comments, groped or even assaulted by male trainers and co-drivers during cross-country trips.

After the lawsuit was filed, EEOC eventually said it was bringing claims on behalf of 270 women and alleged CRST had a practice of tolerating harassment. The company disputed the allegations, saying that it had internal procedures for reporting, investigating and taking action to stop harassment.

Reade eventually dismissed all the claims on a variety of legal grounds, including the statute of limitations and EEOC’s failure to have some of the women deposed by a court deadline. In 2010, she ordered the EEOC to pay $4.5 million in legal costs, blasting it for a “sue first, ask questions later” litigation strategy.

The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the fee award last year and reinstated Starke’s claim, but largely upheld Reade’s other rulings, agreeing that EEOC must investigate the claims of every potential victim and seek informal settlements before filing class-action lawsuits. The agency says the standard has made it harder to pursue similar class-action cases in the 8th Circuit, which spans from North Dakota to Arkansas.

Text Only
AP story section
  • Iraq violence threatens OPEC's precarious balance NEW YORK (AP) -- The oil market has balanced out quite nicely for OPEC in recent years. Now, upheaval in Iraq shows that balance may be more precarious than it has seemed. Dramatic changes in oil production around the globe have offset each other ins

    June 13, 2014

  • Board of Trade Grain mixed, livestock mostly higher CHICAGO (AP) -- Grain futures were mixed Thursday in early trading on the Chicago Board of Trade. Wheat for July delivery was 1 cent higher at $5.9025 a bushel; July corn was 1.25 cents lower at $4.4075 a bushel; July oats were unchanged at $3.4625 a

    June 13, 2014

  • Health campaign among nation's costliest CHICAGO -- President Barack Obama's home state agreed to spend $33 million in federal money promoting his health care law, hiring a high-priced public relations firm for work that initially was mocked and spending far more per enrollee on television

    June 13, 2014

  • Some states roll back teacher tenure protections WASHINGTON (AP) -- Even before a judge's scathing ruling against California's teacher tenure policies, the once-sacred protections that make it harder to fire teachers already had been weakened in many states -- and even removed altogether in some pl

    June 13, 2014

  • Tigers' Scherzer outduels Sale CHICAGO -- Max Scherzer already has a Cy Young Award. Now he has a complete game. Scherzer tossed a three-hitter in his 179th career start for his first complete game and Victor Martinez hit his 16th homer to lead the Detroit Tigers to a 4-0 win over

    June 13, 2014

  • $40M casino for rural Iowa approved BURLINGTON (AP) -- The Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission has voted 3-2 to grant a license for a $40 million casino development that would be located in rural central Iowa. Supporters of the Jefferson casino burst into applause during a meeting in Bur

    June 13, 2014

  • Principal case leads to two hearings RED OAK -- Two hearings are planned related to a southwest Iowa school district's plan to fire a high school principal. The Council Bluffs Daily Nonpareil reported the effort to fire Red Oak High School Principal Jedd Sherman will be the subject of a

    June 13, 2014

  • U.S. split outgrows voting booth WASHINGTON (AP) -- Political polarization in America has broken out of the voting booth. A new survey from the Pew Research Center finds Americans are divided by ideology and partisanship not only when they cast ballots, but also in choosing where to

    June 13, 2014

  • Cubs' offense no help for Samardzija PITTSBURGH -- Jeff Samardzija has some advice his pitching brethren when it comes to facing streaking Andrew McCutchen. Don't. The way the Chicago Cubs' ace looks at it, trying to get the Pittsburgh Pirates' star out at the moment only opens yourself

    June 13, 2014

  • State to reopen Juvenile Home DES MOINES -- A district court judge on Wednesday ordered the state to reopen the Iowa Juvenile Home, telling Gov. Terry Branstad he cannot unilaterally change a law approved by the state Legislature. Judge Scott Rosenberg said the home in Toledo was

    February 6, 2014

AP Video
National News