The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Clinton

October 17, 2013

Closing statements begin in legal malpractice trial

DAVENPORT — After nearly 12 days of testimony, closing arguments started Wednesday in the city of Clinton’s legal malpractice suit against the attorney who represented it in a 2009 federal False Claims Act lawsuit.

The city is suing Michael Walker and his law firm Hopkins and Huebner, claiming they were negligent in their representation of the city in a lawsuit brought by former Clinton firefighter Timothy Schultheis that alleged the city knowingly submitted false ambulance claims to Medicare and Medicaid.

In 2010, the city settled that case for $4.5 million, which leaders now claim was too much, too soon and the result of Walker’s negligence. The city is seeking $4.67 million to recoup the costs of the settlement as well as attorney and expert fees.

Two questions need to be answered, the city’s attorney, Mike Hannafan, told jurors as he delivered his closing arguments Wednesday afternoon. First, would the city have won the False Claims Act case either by getting it dismissed or in trial if it had been represented by a competent attorney? Second, did Walker and his law firm commit legal malpractice?

The city’s False Claims Act case was Walker’s “guinea pig,” Hannafan said.

Walker has testified he had not heard of the False Claims Act before accepting the city’s case, practicing mainly in litigation, municipal law and insurance. Hannafan likened Walker’s work on the case to a family doctor trying to perform brain surgery.

“He saw a chance to make the big time and make a lot of money for his firm,” Hannafan said.

Hannafan criticized Walker’s handling of the case, using the testimony from the False Claims Act expert the city retained, Ronald Clark.

The defense’s legal expert, Guy Cook, wasn’t believable, Hannafan said. Cook was recently chastised by U.S. District Chief Judge Linda Reade for violating a rule that prevents attorneys or anyone working for them from contacting jurors after a case has been decided. Cook also, by his own admission, was not a False Claims Act expert and did not read the settlement agreement when forming his opinion that Walker was not negligent. Hannafan also contended that Cook was biased towards Walker and his attorney Bob Waterman because Cook had represented the senior partner from Walker’s firm in a case several years ago.

Text Only
Clinton
  • 4-15-14 jail photo County hears jail proposal

    CLINTON -- A needs assessment study on the Clinton County Jail and communications department is bringing forth more questions on how the city and county will proceed. Former Clinton County Justice Coordinating Commission Coordinator Brian McKenrick a

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sex abuse trial under way in Clinton CLINTON -- Prosecutors will present their case today in the trial of a Clinton man accused of sexual abusing a 3-year-old girl. The trial against Russell S. McColley, 39, began late Monday afternoon. He is charged with second-degree sexual abuse, a c

    April 15, 2014

  • 4-15-14 Clinton School Board Meeting School board finalizes new budget, cuts positions CLINTON -- Cutting 11 district staff positions to make up for a $636,000 shortfall wasn't an easy task for the Clinton School Board, but was a necessary step in balancing the 2014-2015 budget. That budget received unanimous approval Monday as Clinton

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Gateway to Octagon CLINTON -- Todd Monaghan isn't the type who most would consider a fighter, but that's exactly what his next mission is. Monaghan, a Clinton native, will compete in Fox Sports 1's latest edition of The Ultimate Fighter, which begins Wednesday at 9 p.m

    April 15, 2014

  • Clinton hammered in road-trip opener DAYTON, Ohio -- Gloomy skies, gloomy performance. The Clinton LumberKings began a six-game road trip Monday night against the Midwest League Eastern Division-leading Dayton Dragons with a 13-5 loss. The Dragons scored two runs in the first inning and

    April 15, 2014

  • AGENDA: Traffic Study Commission

    The Traffic Study Commission will meet tomorrow at 4:45 in the City Council Chambers. Click on the link below to view the agenda.

    April 14, 2014

  • AGENDA: Clinton Community School Board

    The Clinton Community School Board will meet tonight at 5 p.m. at the Clinton Administration Center.

    Click the link below to view the meeting agenda.

    April 14, 2014

  • Tonight's CHS soccer match postponed

    The Clinton High School boys' soccer match against West Liberty scheduled for tonight has been postponed. The match is rescheduled for April 25 at Clinton High School starting at 5:00 p.m.

    April 14, 2014

  • IMG_1031.jpg Legislators: Session lacks productivity

    CLINTON -- Iowa legislators are frustrated with the way this year's session has unfolded, but not everything has come with disappointing results. During a legislative coffee gathering Saturday, Sen. Rita Hart, Rep. Steve Olson and Rep. Mary Wolfe exp

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • Women's Expo set for Tuesday at Wild Rose CLINTON -- It is time again to gather the girlfriends and head out to the Ultimate Spring Women's Expo at the Wild Rose Event Center in Clinton. The third annual expo from 5:30 p.m. to 8 p.m. Tuesday, hosted by the Clinton Herald, offers an opportuni

    April 14, 2014

Clinton Herald Photos


Browse, buy and submit pictures with our photo site.

Facebook