The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Clinton

October 9, 2013

Trial update: Ratio not a benchmark

Expert witness testifies quoted ratio was not national average as touted

CLINTON — The ratio touted as the national average for emergency medical services bills as the city faced accusations of Medicare fraud was never meant to be regarded as such, according to the man credited with introducing the ratio.  

Emergency medical services specialist Douglas Wolfberg’s deposition was read into the record Tuesday, disclosing that the 60 or 70 percent ALS, 40 or 30 percent BLS ratio, which attorney Michael Walker relayed to the council as it moved forward with the emergency services lawsuit, was never meant to be taken as more than anecdotal.

During the seventh day of the city’s legal malpractice suit against Walker and his law firm Hopkins and Huebner, both parties read from transcripts of Wolfberg’s deposition, which was taken in Decemeber in Pennsylvania.  

The city is suing Walker because it claims he failed to properly analyze a federal False Claims Act suit that former firefighter Timohty Schultheis filed in 2008. Schultheis alleged the city was improperly billing ambulance runs at an advanced life support level instead of a basic life support level in order to get higher reimbursements from Medicare and Medicaid. That suit ended with the city settling with Schultheis and the U.S. Department of Justice for $4.5 million in 2010.  

Walker retained Wolfberg in March 2010 as an expert witness for the city and subsequently provided him with record summaries and patient care reports, forms paramedics fill out after an ambulance run that includes the ALS or BLS code.

At the time in question under the suit, the city had a 99 percent ALS rate in Medicare billings.  

The 60/40 or 70/30 ratio was never meant to be and was likely not conveyed to Walker as a national standard, Wolfberg said. The ratio was relayed to the council as the average and used to determine the potential fines the city could have faced.   

“You know what? I never gave anyone a national average and no one should be making more of that brief, informal conversation than it was,” Wolfberg said in his deposition.  

Despite the fact that his ratio wasn’t based on any statistical data or analysis, Wolfberg maintained that in regards to ALS rates “if higher than 70 percent, someone has some explaining to do.”

Even with the city’s high ALS rate, Wolfberg said he told Walker there were possible defenses for the case and maintained that opinion at the time of his deposition.   

During his deposition reading, the jury also learned Wolfberg only did a cursory review of the city of Clinton’s ambulance records and never determined if the city’s Medicare or Medicaid claims were appropriately billed.    

“A thorough review couldn’t be done,” Wolfberg said in his deposition.  

According to Wolfberg’s deposition, he began to inventory the records he was given, but upon finding duplicate reports with different information, his work was halted.  

When he reached out to Walker, Wolfberg was directed to EMS Director Andy McGovern, Wolfberg said.  

When asked about the duplicate reports, McGovern told Wolfberg it was due to a change in the software and gave opinions that “weren’t helpful,” according to Wolfberg’s testimony. Wolfberg said he was skeptical of McGovern’s explanation, though Wolfberg admittedly is not a computer expert.  

Wolfberg asked for the dispatch records so he could determine which report had the proper information on it, but was told by McGovern that there were no dispatch records, according to Wolfberg’s testimony.  

“I felt like I was getting the run around,” Wolfberg said.

While he ran a report to get a random sampling of the city’s records for an audit, it was “crystal clear” an audit was never done, Wolfberg said in his deposition. Wolfberg has previously testified that he only reviewed 60 records.  

According to his bills, Wolfberg didn’t perform any work on the city’s case between March 23 and July 10, 2010. From July 10 to July 30, 2010 he devoted 18.1 hours to the Schultheis case.  

While he never formed an opinion on the city’s billing, Wolfberg did form an informal one on the $4.5 million settlement. He was surprised at the amount based on the size of Clinton, he said.

SARAH NOLAN

Following Wolfberg’s deposition reading, Clinton accounting specialist Sarah Nolan took the stand.  

She was never told to bill everything as ALS, nor did she ever upcode claims in an attempt to get the extra $40 to $50 from Medicare or Medicaid that an ALS claim yielded, she testified. Quite the contrary, she said. While she may have made mistakes, she tried to be as accurate as possible and felt comfortable that she was submitting accurate information to insurance companies and the government.  

Nolan was not a certified coder and relied on the summaries prepared by the fire department for the information she entered on the claims, she testified. Patient care reports were not part of her data entry and she would not cross check them for information, she said. Further, she testified, she was not responsible for verifying the codes, but was responsible for entering correct data.

She was not trained in ambulance coding, which she mentioned to McGovern and her boss during the time under scrutiny in the False Claims Act case, former finance director Deb Neels, Nolan testified. Neels told Nolan she did not need to be trained in codes, Nolan said. She also was not trained in the ALS assessment rule.

“I determined based on the patient summary report provided by the fire department,” Nolan said.

It was not until she was deposed by Walker’s attorney, Bob Waterman, for the legal malpractice suit that she learned people billing the claims had any responsibility for checking accuracy, she said.  

There was some contact with the fire department regarding the billings, Nolan testified. At times, she would contact McGovern for clarification on a diagnosis code required for the report. This happened maybe once a month, she said.

After McGovern and former fire chief Mark Regenwether met with Assistant U.S. Attorney Maureen McGuire and federal investigator Kory Ihnken in February 2009, Nolan said she was told there weren’t any problems with the billings, but was instructed to ensure a second diagnosis code was on the claims.  

The next time Nolan heard about the Medicare or Medicaid billing or coding complaints was in September 2009 when Schultheis’ suit was unsealed, she testified. Her involvement in the case was limited to an initial meeting with Walker, McGovern, former city attorney Paul Walter, and Regenwether; putting together records to be sent to Walker; and a 2010 conference call with McGovern, Neels and Wolfberg, she testified.  

During the conference call Wolfberg went into great detail about ALS and BLS, which Nolan testified she understood was significant because Clinton’s ALS rate was in the high 90s. Wolfberg said this was concerning, Nolan testified.  

Nolan’s testimony concluded Tuesday. McGovern started his testimony Tuesday and will continue today.

1
Text Only
Clinton
  • School board set to analyze survey CLINTON - The results of the Clinton School Board's open enroll out survey are in, and district officials are set to analyze them. Board member Eric Gettes, who has spearheaded the campaign to understand why families have left the district, informed

    April 22, 2014

  • Calling all munchkins CLINTON -- The Clinton Area Showboat Theatre is looking for munchkins. Local auditions will be held from 6 to 8 p.m. Monday, May 19, at the Showboat for munchkins in the upcoming "The Wizard of Oz" performance. Munchkins may be of any age as long as

    April 22, 2014

  • St. Paul grants Church awards grants

    CLINTON -- An area church recently awarded area organizations with grants. The Bickelhaupt Arboretum, the Felix Adler Children's Discovery Center, First Circle Friends, YWCA, Voices for the Land/Monarch Teacher Network and Haley Westerkamp were grant

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • 4-22-14 CCC Pay it Forward Week CCC gives back to community CLINTON -- A community college is defined as a junior college offering a higher education to people living in a particular area. For the staff, faculty and students at Clinton Community College the definition of community plays a much bigger role tha

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Kness photo Leader, wife run on in fight against cancer FORT BRAGG, N.C. - Fort Bragg Soldier Col. Lenny Kness, chief of staff, 1st Sustainment Command (Theater), is an avid runner. So, it was no surprise in October 2011 that he would stay the course, as planned many months before, and run the Army Ten M

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • On Iowa program selects Clinton residents CLINTON -- Four Clinton residents recently were named On Iowa student leaders. Keaton Fuller, Jacinta Jargo, Kenya Lewis and Allyson Naeve were among 235 people selected to serve as welcomers to new first-year and transfer students at the University

    April 22, 2014

  • Middle School photo 2 Touring the unfinished Clinton MS (With Video)

    CLINTON -- Project manager Eric White and his construction group Estes are still half a year away from unveiling the new Clinton Middle School. Even though weather has set workers back by nearly three months, school officials were pleased with the bu

    April 22, 2014 4 Photos

  • Kings' DeCarlo has another big late hit CLINTON -- In a game that went back and forth, Clinton ended with the last laugh. Clinton (9-7) defeated Quad Cities 7-6 on Monday at Ashford University Field, thanks to an eighth inning that saw a hit batsmen and an RBI double to extend its winning

    April 22, 2014

  • Work still needed on legal services CLINTON -- During Tuesday's meeting, the Clinton City Council is expected to finalize its agreement with Cedar Rapids firm Lynch Dallas, officially filling Clinton's city attorney void that has lasted nearly five months. The firm's scope, spelled ou

    April 21, 2014

  • Choral group marks 10th anniversary CLINTON -- A Clinton choral group will celebrate its 10th anniversary this weekend. RiverChor will celebrate the anniversary at 2 p.m. Sunday at Zion Lutheran Church. The concert is free, but donations will be accepted. A reception will be held in th

    April 21, 2014

Clinton Herald Photos


Browse, buy and submit pictures with our photo site.

Facebook