The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Lifestyles

January 10, 2013

State court denies Wal-Mart appeal

DES MOINES — A state court denied an appeal by a construction company and Wal-Mart involving an incident in Clinton that resulted in more than $300,000 in damages awarded to a man in 2012.

The Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed a ruling by a Clinton County jury that awarded Patrick J. O’Bryan $344,000 for Wal-Mart and Henry Carlson Company’s negligence involving a fall O’Bryan suffered in 2008 at Clinton’s Wal-Mart. The jury found that each party was responsible, putting 35 percent of the blame on O’Bryan and Wal-Mart, and 30 percent on HCC.

According to court documents, O’Bryan stepped into a hole located outside of the vendor receiving door at Wal-Mart on June 20, 2008, while delivering bread for his employer, Sara Lee Bakery. The area was under construction, and HCC was responsible for the construction.

Days later, O’Bryan reported the incident to his supervisor, and eventually filed an incident report with Sara Lee.

O’Bryan was treated for injuries, but without significant improvement, a medical official recommended surgery for the injury suffered at the construction site. More than a year after the surgery, O’Bryan filed a petition alleging Wal-Mart and HCC were negligent in causing the injuries.

On Jan. 30, 2012, the case moved to trial, where jury members heard from 24 witnesses and saw more than 60 exhibits during the six-day trial.

HCC and Wal-Mart presented testimony disputing O’Bryan’s negligence claim, including the existence and location of the hole in question, the cause of O’Bryan’s injury, the amount of damages incurred, and whether O’Bryan failed to mitigate those damages. The jury, instead, voted against those claims.

Wal-Mart and HCC filed motions for judgment notwithstanding verdict and motions for a new trial, but the district court denied the motions.

“There was substantial evidence introduced on both sides of each hotly contested issue relating to liability and damages and it is not for the court to substitute its judgment for the jury’s judgment with respect to these fact issues,” the court wrote.

When appealing to the Iowa Court of Appeals, Wal-Mart and HCC believed the court erred in allowing a photograph to be shown and believed its motion for a new trial should be granted. The picture, an image of O’Bryan on a couch with a small American flag pillow, was shown as evidence by the prosecution during the trial. HCC and Wal-Mart objected to the exhibit, based on relevance, foundation and prejudice. The trial court overruled the objection, and admitted the exhibit into evidence.

O’Bryan maintained the photograph was introduced as evidence of his mental suffering following the injury. HCC and Wal-Mart argued the photograph was introduced as evidence of O’Bryan’s financial status to elicit sympathy from the jury.

Also, Wal-Mart and HCC moved for a new trial based on allegations that inconsistency evidence made the jury prejudice.

Both of those claims were denied by the court.

“The jury’s verdict does not appear to be the result of passion or prejudice, is supported by substantial evidence, and administers substantial justice between the parties,” the Court of Appeals wrote.

1
Text Only
Lifestyles
  • Student leadership Alumni honor students at luncheon CLINTON -- Clinton Community College student leaders were recognized at a student leader luncheon. The CCC Alumni Association honored 30 students, who were nominated by the CCC staff and faculty for showing leadership in the classroom, on campus and

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • EICC to host career fair DAVENPORT-- Manufacturing jobs are available for those who look for them. Eastern Iowa Community College's Blong Technology Center is helping in that search with its upcoming Advanced Manufacturing Career Fair, from 2 to 6 p.m April 29. Several area

    April 18, 2014

  • CCC Veterans Association host 'Honor Flight' showing CLINTON -- The Clinton Community College Student Veterans Association will be host a public showing of the Honor Flight Movie at 6 p.m. Thursday, May 8. The movie will be shown at Clinton Community College Auditorium, 1000 Lincoln Blvd., Clinton. The

    April 17, 2014

  • Sound of Music Screenings showcase films at TLP MOUNT CARROLL, Ill. -- Timber Lake Playhouse will host two events next month. A sing-along "Sound of Music" event will be held at 6:30 p.m. Saturday, May 3, and at 2 p.m. Sunday, May 4, at the Mount Carroll theater. A screening of "Young Frankenstein

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • April is Donate Life Month

    CLINTON -- The month of April is National Donate Life Month across the United States. Hospitals across the nation, like Mercy Medical Center in Clinton, join to recognize the impact that organ and tissue donations make and to honor the generosity of

    April 17, 2014

  • Screen shot 2014-04-11 at 4.49.09 PM.png Train, entertain your pets with these 3 smartphone apps

    While they may not have thumbs to use the phone, pets can benefit from smartphone apps designed specifically for them.

    April 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • Alternatives available for addicts DEAR ANNIE: I enjoy reading your column and agree with most of your advice, including your recommendations when it comes to handling alcohol addictions and binge drinking. I do not work in this field, but I've seen alternatives to AA that may be more

    April 12, 2014

  • Peace Soup Peace Soup completes 7th year CLINTON -- Peace Soup concluded its seventh year this week. Peace Soup was held for five Tuesdays during the Lenten season. The series for 2014, "Interfaith Connections to Peace," featured the topic of Christianity. Elizabeth Liggett, pastor at St.

    April 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • Milkweed plants Raising awareness of milkweed MAQUOKETA -- The Hurstville Interpretive Center will attempt to raise public awareness about milkweed plants. The center is holding a plant sale for area residents to try to include more milkweed plants in the region for monarch butterflies. The sale

    April 10, 2014 1 Photo

  • Women's club extends sale CLINTON -- The Clinton Women's Club has extended the deadline for the group's annual silent auction. The deadline for bids is through Saturday for the purse and bag silent auction at the George Curtis Mansion, 420 Fifth Ave. South. During this past w

    April 9, 2014

Elections
Front page
Clinton Herald Photos


Browse, buy and submit pictures with our photo site.

Poll

Should the city of Clinton appeal the open records violation ruling that will cost taxpayers $40,600?

Yes
No
     View Results
AP Video
Olympics 2014
Featured Comment
Featured Ads
Blue Zones Project
Parade
Magazine

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.