The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Local News

October 8, 2013

Mayor Vulich takes the stand during Walker trial

DAVENPORT — UPDATE: Settling was the only option Mayor Mark Vulich saw when he and then fellow council members unanimously approved the $4.5 million settlement over alleged Medicare fraud, he testified Monday.  

Vulich took the stand Monday afternoon as a witness in the city's legal malpractice suit. The city is suing Michael Walker and his law firm Hopkins and Huebner. The city retained Walker in late September 2009 to represent the city in the False Claims Act case that resulted in the city settling with whistleblower Timothy Schultheis and the federal government for $4.5 million in 2010.

Schultheis alleged the city was billing all ambulance calls as advanced life support instead of basic life support to receive higher reimbursement rates from Medicare and Medicaid.  

The city's goal is to recoup the expenses of the settlement along with other fees, totaling $4.67 million.

At the time of the False Claims suit Vulich was an at-large councilman. He told the jury Monday that based on Walker's advice, settling seemed like the only option. Walker himself had started exploring the option in March 2010, according to a letter to Schultheis' attorney asking if his client had a settlement demand. The city council during a closed session on April 13, 2010 told Walker to move forward with trying to settle, authorizing him to offer $1 million.  

The decision to move forward with a settlement came less than seven months after the council first learned it was being sued and retained Walker.

While Walker in his initial council appearance on Sept. 29, 2009, had presented the council with a number of options the city could employ to defend itself in the False Claims Act case, he was not as optimistic when he returned in April 2010, Vulich testified.  

In the months between the initial and the April meeting, Walker had reviewed records, met with city staff responsible for coding and billing along with other department heads and retained purported billing expert Douglas Wolfberg. Vulich testified that in April 2010 Walker told the council he was concerned based on what he had found in his investigation.

"Basically we were in big trouble. That's how I interpreted it," Vulich said.  "It appeared we had gone into a no-win situation."  

Walker never showed the council a scenario where it could win the Schultheis case, Vulich said. Walker informed the council the city had budgeted for 100 percent ALS and in fact billed 99 percent ALS, far above the national average of 60 percent that Wolfberg said was the benchmark. Council members had never heard these numbers before, Vulich testified. In fact, Vulich said he had never heard about ALS or BLS coding or billing before he learned the city was facing the lawsuit.

At the same time, the council was aware Walker had not reviewed the ALS ratios for other towns in the region. Walker also told the council he had tried to get copies of the dispatch records to prove the ambulance calls were as serious as they were billed, but the records were not available, Vulich testified.

When he returned for the Aug. 3 closed session of the city council, which happened in the same day as a mediation with Schultheis, Walker told the council a $4.5 million settlement was on the table and recommended the city take it.

"I was very unhappy. I was shocked we had gotten into such a mess," Vulich said.  

Still, he and fellow council members decided to move forward with the settlement. Vulich credits his decision to his belief there were no other options based on what Walker had told the council.  

When asked by Walker's attorney Bob Waterman on Monday if he had ever asked Walker any questions in the course of Walker's work on the suit, Vulich said he asked Walker if the city's insurance covered its liability for the alleged fraud. Walker was unable to answer the question. Other than this one instance, Vulich testified, he couldn't recall any other questions he asked Walker that went unanswered.

Neither Vulich nor any other council members said the council should wait to settle pending further investigation or more expert opinions, he testified.  

On Aug. 30, 2010, the council formally approved the settlement. The first payment was made on Oct. 1, 2010. The city has made three $450,000 payments and will make another this month.  

Three months later, Vulich learned a number of facts that made him reconsider. During the Civil Service Commission hearing on Nov. 23, 2010, Vulich learned no one had looked at the ambulance runs to see if they had been billed appropriately, Wolfberg had reviewed only 60 patient care reports and had not formed an opinion on the city's billing and no one had looked into a computer glitch that had been blamed for the city producing duplicate reports. It also was the first time Vulich had ever heard former fire chief Mark Regenwether's and EMS Director Andy McGovern's sides of the story.

At the end of that hearing, Vulich had formed a new opinion.  

"It didn't appear Mr. Walker had done any investigation. There were a lot of questions I thought should have been answered that weren't," Vulich said.  

In December 2010, the city council directed City Attorney Jeff Farwell to look at what the city's options were for pursuing legal malpractice. The legal malpractice suit was filed on March 28, 2012.

Text Only
Local News
  • John Hood A year after 'chaos'

    It happened two hours after John Hood finished his run. Like many, he thought the loud boom was just the sound of cannons going off, something that shook the ground. It was odd, but Hood — a 1989 Clinton High School graduate — tried to make it logical, associating the noise with another good happening at the Boston Marathon.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Clinton looks into roadway safety upgrades Herald Staff Report Clinton looks into roadway safety upgrades

    April 19, 2014

  • Theft trial for man charged in Wolfe sisters' murders

    A western Pennsylvania man accused of having robbed and killed his next-door neighbors, two sisters of Iowa Rep. Mary Wolfe, now also faces trial on charges that he stole another woman's wedding ring a year ago.

    State police in Greensburg allege that 43-year-old Allen Wade of East Liberty, Pa., stole the ring while delivering a refrigerator to a home in April 2013. Westmoreland County Common Pleas Judge Rita Hathaway on Thursday agreed to schedule the case for trial.

    April 18, 2014

  • More felonies added to sex abuse charges CLINTON -- A Clinton man already facing multiple felony charges for allegedly sexually abusing a child is now facing six more felonies for sexual exploitation of a child. Tony D. James, 45, was charged this past weekend with six counts of sexual expl

    April 18, 2014

  • Wildlife service to conduct burnings CLINTON -- The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service will conduct several prescribed burns this spring. The burns will take place on the Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife and Fish Refuge in Carroll and Jo Daviess counties. Sites planned for burning

    April 18, 2014

  • Women jailed on meth charges

    CLINTON -- Two Clinton women are currently being held in the Clinton County jail on $50,000 cash-only bonds for methamphetamine charges. Jessica L. Crabtree, 29, 215 10th Ave. North, and Tera A. Riddle, 27, 611 1/2 S. Seventh St., were arrested last

    April 18, 2014

  • Photo exhibit 2 'Hats Off' Art exhibit covers downtown (With Map & Video)

    CLINTON -- A clown. Clinton High wrestlers. An expecting mother. A young Mozart. These faces and more all peered through downtown storefronts Thursday. They're there again today, too. Looking back at them was photographer Jean Black. They are her way

    April 18, 2014 3 Photos

  • Fire alarm evacuation at Eagle Heights

    Students of Eagle Heights Elementary School were evacuated Thursday afternoon after staff smelled something being emitted in the first-grade hallway and main office areas.

    According to a press release from the Clinton Community School District, staff noticed the smell at approximately 1:10 p.m. It was then determined the fire department should be notified, and the fire alarm was pulled. The building was evacuated quickly and the Clinton Fire Department responded immediately.

    April 17, 2014

  • UPDATED: McColley found not guilty of sex abuse

    Relief showed on the faces of Russell McColley and his family Thursday as a verdict of not guilty was read in court.
    "Our prayers were answered, that's all I have to say," Tracy Hook, McColley's sister, said.
    McColley was facing a charge of second-degree sexual abuse. If he had been convicted of the class B felony, he could have faced as much as 25 years in prison.

    April 17, 2014

  • Court denies man's appeal in robbery CLINTON -- The Iowa Court of Appeals has upheld a conviction of a man who robbed a Clinton pawn shop in 2012. Darrell L. Thomas recently appealed his first-degree robbery conviction to the Iowa Court of Appeals. The court released its decision Wednes

    April 17, 2014

Clinton Herald photos

Browse, buy and submit pictures with our photo site.