The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Local News

February 17, 2014

Judge rules against firefighter's discrimination claim

CLINTON — A Clinton County District Court judge has ruled against a female Clinton firefighter who claimed her rights were violated when superiors refused to put her on light duty while she was pregnant.

"The Court finds that the City's policy does not infringe on Mrs. (Karen) McQuistion's fundamental right to procreate," Clinton County District Court Judge Henry Latham wrote in the 13-page judgment, which was filed late last week.

Serving with the fire department since January 2001, McQuistion became aware that she was pregnant on May 9, 2011. According to the court ruling, she notified her battalion chief, Joel Atkinson, of her pregnancy, requesting to be put on light duty. This includes inspections, water hydrant checks, fire prevention, duties, training assignments and duties with the juvenile fire offender program.

In June 2011, then-Fire Chief Mark Regenwether, former City Attorney Jeffrey Farwell and former City Administrator Jeffrey Horne met to discuss her pregnancy and rejected her request for light duty work. McQuistion stopped working on Sept. 29, 2011 and returned to work on March 14, 2012, with the same pay and benefits she had previously received. She filed her lawsuit on March 28, 2012.

In his ruling, Latham considered pregnancy discrimination under the Iowa Civil Rights Acts, which requires pregnant employees to be considered as having "temporary disabilities" and that the same terms and conditions are applied as for other temporary disabilities. McQuistion's lawsuit had claimed that the fire department offers light duty to other firefighters with disabilities. However, Latham stated in his ruling that this does not apply to the plaintiff.

"The conditions of the City's policy are clear. If an employee is disabled on the job, the City must provide her with light duty work. If an employee is disabled off the job, the City is not required to provide her light duty work," Latham stated. "McQuistion's disability was acquired off the job."

McQuistion's lawsuit also referenced two Clinton police women who were given light duty during their pregnancies. However, Latham determined McQuistion is not "similarly situated" to the pregnant police officers because police and firefighters fall under different collective bargaining agreements. Since these were the only two city employees that McQuistion had referenced to prove different treatment from the city, Latham denied her equal protection argument.

In her lawsuit, McQuistion argued that the city's policy infringed upon her fundamental right to procreate. Latham disagreed with her and found she was in fact arguing her employer was obligated to provide her with certain advantages that she would not be normally provided "to mitigate the natural disadvantages that come with pregnancy."

"That is not the law," Latham wrote. "If the city had implemented its policy in order to explicitly or implicitly punish female employees for choosing to have children, that policy would infringe on the fundamental right to procreate. In the present case, Mrs. McQuistion has not provided evidence of Defendant's motive to do so."

Attempts to reach McQuistion and her attorney Roxanne Conlin for comment were unsuccessful.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • More felonies added to sex abuse charges CLINTON -- A Clinton man already facing multiple felony charges for allegedly sexually abusing a child is now facing six more felonies for sexual exploitation of a child. Tony D. James, 45, was charged this past weekend with six counts of sexual expl

    April 18, 2014

  • Wildlife service to conduct burnings CLINTON -- The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service will conduct several prescribed burns this spring. The burns will take place on the Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife and Fish Refuge in Carroll and Jo Daviess counties. Sites planned for burning

    April 18, 2014

  • Women jailed on meth charges CLINTON -- Two Clinton women are currently being held in the Clinton County jail on $50,000 cash-only bonds for methamphetamine charges. Jessica L. Crabtree, 29, 215 10th Ave. North, and Tera A. Riddle, 27, 611 1/2 S. Seventh St., were arrested last

    April 18, 2014

  • Photo exhibit 2 'Hats Off' Art exhibit covers downtown

    CLINTON -- A clown. Clinton High wrestlers. An expecting mother. A young Mozart. These faces and more all peered through downtown storefronts Thursday. They're there again today, too. Looking back at them was photographer Jean Black. They are her way

    April 18, 2014 3 Photos

  • Fire alarm evacuation at Eagle Heights

    Students of Eagle Heights Elementary School were evacuated Thursday afternoon after staff smelled something being emitted in the first-grade hallway and main office areas.

    According to a press release from the Clinton Community School District, staff noticed the smell at approximately 1:10 p.m. It was then determined the fire department should be notified, and the fire alarm was pulled. The building was evacuated quickly and the Clinton Fire Department responded immediately.

    April 17, 2014

  • UPDATED: McColley found not guilty of sex abuse

    Relief showed on the faces of Russell McColley and his family Thursday as a verdict of not guilty was read in court.
    "Our prayers were answered, that's all I have to say," Tracy Hook, McColley's sister, said.
    McColley was facing a charge of second-degree sexual abuse. If he had been convicted of the class B felony, he could have faced as much as 25 years in prison.

    April 17, 2014

  • Court denies man's appeal in robbery CLINTON -- The Iowa Court of Appeals has upheld a conviction of a man who robbed a Clinton pawn shop in 2012. Darrell L. Thomas recently appealed his first-degree robbery conviction to the Iowa Court of Appeals. The court released its decision Wednes

    April 17, 2014

  • Dutch Days grand marshals Fulton couple honored as grand marshals

    Bob and Trudy Feldt have been dedicated to the city of Fulton for decades. Whether it be Trudy's 27-year commitment to teaching the children of the community at the River Bend School District, Bob's 33-year career with the Fulton-born c

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • CCDA will match funds to secure van

    CLINTON -- One local non-profit organization soon will benefit from a donation from the Clinton County Development Association but it's not their typical form of grant giving. During a meeting Wednesday, CCDA members discussed the possibility of matc

    April 17, 2014

  • Jury deliberating in sex abuse case CLINTON -- Jurors were set to return to court this morning to continue deliberating on the trial of a man accused of sexually abusing a 3-year-old girl. The jury deliberated for more than two hours on the Russell McColley case Wednesday afternoon, be

    April 17, 2014

Facebook
Clinton
Camanche
Fulton
Clinton Herald photos


Browse, buy and submit pictures with our photo site.