The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa


June 29, 2012

LEVINE: New bowl system creates equality for teams

CLINTON — Periodically in this space I write about other things than chasing around my 2-year-old and since it’s too hot to think about a new development in my parenting life, I’m going with a topic that comes naturally to me — football.

Sure, it’s not even July and the temperatures are so high that my daughter even complains about the slide at the park being too hot, but it’s never too early to start thinking about cool, fall mornings, tailgating outside with family and friends, and enjoying an entire weekend’s worth of non-stop football. And when a major change happens in the middle of summer that will completely alter college football, I can justify writing about football just a little bit more.

University presidents on Tuesday agreed on a plan to conduct a Final Four-esque playoff in Division I college football starting in 2014. The move comes after years of passionate pleas from fans to institute something different from the BCS bowl system choosing a national champion.

However, unlike many fans of college football, I stood firm in a stance on not reducing the greatness of college football’s regular season with a playoff system featuring multiple teams. My argument then, and still now, is to take a look at college basketball. Their regular season is almost meaningless because virtually no one cares about the regular season and fans only tune into March Madness to see 68 teams attempt to earn a national championship.

College football’s uniqueness comes from a great regular season where every game matters. In college basketball, only March matters.

But after years of defending the BCS and bowl system, I came to a crossroads in 2008, when Oklahoma leapfrogged Texas to reach the national championship. Now I’m sure all my faithful readers remember my classic column from November 2008, but I wrote then about my displeasure with that decision.

Ever since then, I changed my mind (trust me, that doesn’t always happen) and backed a four-team playoff, which will now soon be instituted.

The new system will likely not affect either of the state teams since Iowa State has never come close to finishing in the top 4, and Iowa would have been considered once in 2002. But this new way of crowning a national champion is the fairest and best way to keep the regular season from being marginalized by an overabundance of teams receiving invites to a postseason for a trophy.

This format also will keep the bowl structure in place, which is a good thing for fans and players. There are definitely too many bowls, but for the most part, the postseason games award teams and mostly fans with an opportunity for a vacation, all the while watching one more football game. Fans enjoy the bragging rights provided by big-name bowls and teams get some national exposure that isn’t always prevalent during the regular season.

I’m still not sold on a selection committee choosing the teams for the four-team playoff. While the NCAA basketball tournament generally does a good job of picking the right teams, there have been plenty of squads deserving of a spot in the tournament, only to not hear their name mentioned on selection Sunday. By using a formula like the BCS, onlookers are kept informed of what everyone needs to do to get into the championship round, and surprises will be limited.

And there’s no doubt there will still be controversy. Once again, just take a look at the basketball tournament to see why that statement is true. The 69th team in the field always feels slighted, even though they obviously didn’t do enough to get into the Big Dance. Any team on the bubble didn’t do enough and shouldn’t have much room to complain, even though it happens every year without fail.

But with the college football system, there’s a lot less difference between No. 4 and 5, than 68 and 69. There are plenty of years where three teams should be in the discussion, while other times five of six teams could vie for the final spot. And then there will be times when two teams have clearly deserved to be the only representatives in the national title game, only to have to go through one more opponent. In the end, though, the university presidents did something they had to do. A playoff needed to be created. Now, I hope they don’t mess it up by adding even more teams.

Scott Levine is the Associate Editor of the Clinton Herald. He can be reached at

Text Only
  • Off and on the record Let us now praise anonymous sources.The new White House press secretary got into a familiar old spat with the White House press corps the other day over the use of anonymous sources.Josh Earnest — has there ever been a more perfectly named White Hous

    July 25, 2014

  • Be more informed

    Blame the city.That is a favorite pastime of many, including me at times. Driving over that pesky pothole or paying that annual property tax bill can lead to some choice words referencing the city. Nobody takes the brunt of being the scapegoat more t

    July 25, 2014

  • CCC thanks community, collaborators for successful movie night Clinton Community College would like to thank those who participated in the free outdoor movie showing of “Captain America – Winter Soldier” on the evening of Friday, July 18.We are grateful to have such wonderful community collaborators in the Erick

    July 25, 2014

  • Lindley, Tom.jpg Better police needed for college teams enticed to cheat

    The NCAA once cracked down on colleges that went too far luring top prospects, then it targeted teams that lathered players with special treatment. That was until the NCAA's get-tough approach backfired, rendering it ineffective and creating an opportunity for those who want to play dirty.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Lindley, Tom.jpg Expectations too high for a rehabbing Woods

    Tiger Woods finished near bottom last weekend at Royal Liverpool, drawing out his drought of major tournament wins. Despite the disappointing showing, Woods' return to form remains a matter of when, not if.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Todd Akin's back again to talk of rape So, Todd Akin is back and he’s talking rape again.You remember what happened last time. The would-be Missouri senator torpedoed his campaign two years ago after suggesting in a TV interview that if a woman is a victim of “legitimate rape,” she is unl

    July 22, 2014

  • Sadness remains as two-year mark passes in cousins' case As most citizens of the Cedar Valley are well aware, July 13 marked two years since the disappearance of cousins Elizabeth Collins and Lyric Cook-Morrissey of Evansdale.The passage of time provides some semblance of healing, but the sadness, particul

    July 22, 2014

  • UI needs to keep its admission standards high There’s been a lot of talk lately — most of it coming from the leadership of the Iowa state Board of Regents — about the University of Iowa not being passionate enough about its recruitment of in-state undergraduates. Regent president Bruce Rastetter

    July 21, 2014

  • Vote fraud myths meet voting rights reality Before she was allowed to register and vote for the first time in Franklin County, North Carolina, Rosanell Eaton had to read the entire preamble to the U.S. Constitution out loud in front of three men in the county courthouse.Eaton is black. The thr

    July 21, 2014 1 Story

  • 7-21-14 David Helscher mug Prepare for possible effects of Fed's decisions It has been more than 5 years since the Federal Reserve has taken unprecedented steps to support the economy through purchases of Treasury and mortgage-backed debt securities. This has generally been called quantitative easing and has not been withou

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo


With the Clinton County Justice Coordinating Commission and the Clinton County Board of Supervisors discussing proposals to construct a new jail, do you think the time has come for Clinton County to construct such a facility?

     View Results