It was a difficult week for Clinton taxpayers.
Citizens learned Monday they will foot the bill for another settlement, and on Wednesday, the city forwarded a sewer rate increase to the next Committee of the Whole meeting.
At this point, I shouldn’t be surprised. Oddly, though, I was, at least with the sewer hike. Residents are becoming numb to city officials settling with former employees and giving up thousands of dollars to avoid trial. But increasing an already over-priced sewer bill, which was raised again in July, caught me off guard.
City Council members approved a 20.7 percent increase earlier this year, giving the city of Clinton the dishonorable position of owning the highest sewer rates in the state of Iowa, eclipsing Boone’s rate of $7.97 per 100 cubic feet.
If a proposed 25 percent increase and 15 percent increase come to fruition in 2013, the average monthly bill would reach $94.08, almost double the $54.32 the same customers paid in July 2011, and that was high compared to the rest of the state.
According to a rate study conducted in 2011, the state median average for water AND sewer bills is a little more than $40 per month. By 2015, that rate study projects the median average monthly bill for water and sewer would rise to $60.30, a bit higher than residents in Clinton were paying for only sewer services in 2011.
But wait. Clinton is the anomaly in the entire state and nation when it comes to problems. Except that’s not true, either, despite the constant dire predictions coming from City Hall.
The city of Burlington is going through budget woes, shifting money into different budgets, including paying attorney fees out of the sewer fund. To help alleviate some of their budget problems, City Council members made the difficult decision to raise rates to $3.28 per 1,000 gallons of water, which amounts to about $2.45 per 100 cubic feet.
Excuse me for being a little underwhelmed by their increases.
In Fort Dodge, rates are raising from $2.80 per 1,000 gallons of water to $3.15 per 1,000 gallons in 2016. Their average monthly bill for 2012 was $22.87.
Oh, and just in case you were wondering, Burlington is on the Mississippi River and has a population of 25,564, while Fort Dodge has 24,981 citizens. Clinton boasts a 26,830 population.
But it’s not just similarly sized cities dealing with sewer rate increases. Knoxville faced tough regulations from the Iowa Department of Natural Resources and raised its rates to $5.82 per 1,000 gallons, equivalent to $4.35 per 100 cubic feet, almost half of Clinton’s current rate of $8.18 per 100 cubic feet.
Elkador also took on sewer improvements, moving its monthly fee from $34 per month to $43.50 per month.
And what about the constant argument regarding the city’s difficulty of delinquent bills? Davenport, Bettendorf and LeClaire are the only other Iowa cities that do not own their water supplied to customers, providing a setback to cities trying to collect sewer fees.
Fortunately for those cities, the problem must not be too bad, considering Bettendorf has the second lowest sewer rates in the state for cities with populations greater than 10,000. Davenport was below the median average for cities with populations greater than 10,000, just below Ames, which is proposing sewer increases on their average $24 monthly bills.
Who’s to blame for Clinton’s problems? I don’t know, but I’m not going to participate in the pastime that the current council has grasped, by blaming everyone else for their problems. The council is pointing fingers at a bad ordinance put in place four years ago during the original increases that delayed payments to the city.
During the blame game, though, it’s never mentioned that six of the eight (including the mayor) City Council members were elected on or before 2009, and if they had acted during their tenure to change that ordinance, this mess could have been avoided.
It’s also not mentioned how during budget time, these extra costs are not accounted for.
Each year, city officials map out a budget, and for the past two years, panic has set in during the fall regarding unexpected expenses.
Either revenue is not being correctly projected or someone isn’t doing their job.
City Council members are elected to keep the city in working order and make Clinton an attractive place to live. With property taxes higher than cities with comparable populations, like Mason City, Marshalltown and Burlington, and service charges going through the roof, it’s impossible to compete with other cities.
Not only do fixed-income residents suffer from escalating charges and taxes, but young families, who can contribute to the growth of cities with new ideas, good-paying jobs and new spirit, are being forced to work in Clinton, but live outside the city limits to avoid being a part of the constant practice of passing on huge increases to citizens willing to pay for services.
It’s time for a new course. Find a different way to fund a bill for a road construction project that was somehow not budgeted for correctly during the multiple budget workshops.
And if the City Council won’t vote “no” to this increase, Mayor Mark Vulich should stand up for the citizens who elected him, and veto anymore increases.
We’ve heard these doomsday predictions before about how the city wouldn’t function without applying another tax hike. I’ve yet to see the city disappear from heeding the advice of outside consultants.
However, if this increase goes through, the only thing the city will see disappear is its people.
Scott Levine is the Associate Editor of the Clinton Herald. He can be reached at email@example.com.
It was a difficult week for Clinton taxpayers.
- It's the present that counts This classic column was originally published Dec. 23, 2000. Now that I have enough money to buy Christmas presents, it seems as if it ought to be easier than it was when I didn't have enough. But it isn't. It turns out money doesn't have much to do w
- When there is no one watching The Black Guerilla Family prison gang controlled the Baltimore City jail. According to a federal indictment, 27 correctional officers, along with 17 others, "were in bed with BGF inmates." That would be literally and figuratively. Gang leader Tavon W
- 10 ways to avoid holiday weight gain On average, Americans gain one to two pounds during the holiday season each year. This weight gain does not seem excessive, but it tends to accumulate over the years. The holidays can be difficult when trying to watch your waistline. Use the followin
- Closing home for juveniles is right call The Iowa Juvenile Home in Toledo is responsible for providing care, education and treatment to Iowa youth who have no other place to go. Some of these kids have been in trouble with the law. Some are judged by a court to be "in need of assistance" be
- The Twelve Days of Christmas come with a heftier price tag For the last-minute holiday shopper I have a suggestion. A financial firm tracks the annual cost of the items included in the carol the "Twelve Days of Christmas." Rather than procrastinate you will probably need to start right away to secure all of
- Resident thankful for grocery bill help To the Good Samaritan who paid for my groceries on Tuesday, December 3, at Aldi's, a very heartfelt thank you. I hope Santa will be good to you this Christmas as you were to me. God bless you! Char Miller, Clinton Resident thankful for grocery bill
- How not to think about the pension crisis The latest news out of Detroit isn't good. To get its fresh start, this once great but now bankrupt city is going to stick it to municipal employees and retirees. City retirees there haven't enjoyed exactly lavish pensions, but what they had was thou
Democrats' double-standard brands opponents of Obamacare
Are the president's critics patriots or obstructionists? That all depends on which president is being criticized.
- Hall of Fame careers built on leadership When managers Bobby Cox, Tony La Russa and Joe Torre were elected to the Hall of Fame, there was universal agreement that the honor was deserved. Not much to debate when the call is unanimous. If anything was strange, though, it was that the trio was
- Why Boehner, fed up, blew up Last spring, as President Barack Obama was beset by IRS scandals, Benghazi backlash and the second-term blues, he was reported by The New York Times to be privately talking about "going Bulworth." The phrase is a reference to a satirical 1998 Warren
- More Opinion Headlines