The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Top News

January 25, 2013

Court denies murder appeal

DES MOINES — A state appeals court has denied a Clinton man’s appeal to overturn his first-degree murder conviction.

The Iowa Court of Appeals on Thursday affirmed a Clinton County jury’s decision to convict Jason Tate of first-degree murder and possession of a firearm by a felon. Tate was found guilty in October 2011 in the shooting death of Kelsey Stahl.

During the murder trial, Tate admitted on the witness stand that he shot Stahl. Tate’s appeal contended that there was insufficient evidence to support the first-degree murder conviction and the court erred in admitting evidence of prior bad acts.

Also, Tate argued in his appeal, and on the witness stand during the trial, that the shooting was accidental. He said the court should not have admitted certain evidence about Stahl.

His appeal also raised issues regarding ineffective assistance from counsel.

Ineffective assistance

Tate argued the court should not have admitted evidence of prior bad acts, including a verbal altercation and bruising on Stahl in the months leading up to her death.  

The appeals court ruled that since Tate waived any alleged error, the admission of prior bad acts would stand or fall on his ineffective assistance of counsel claim.

Tate’s attorney did not object to Phyllis Pickens’ testimony during the trial regarding a verbal altercation between Tate and Stahl. In his appeal, Tate said this should have been objected to, but the appeals court ruled in favor of the counsel based on the exchange being evidence of an emotionally charged relationship.

Tate also said counsel erred in failing to object to testimony that Stahl changed her behavior when Tate moved in with her. Once again, the appeals court ruled in favor of the counsel, saying the testimony of Stahl’s changed behavior outweighed the danger of unfair prejudice.

Lastly, Tate said his counsel did not object to testimony from three witnesses about bruising on Stahl in the months leading up to her death.

However, the counsel cross-examined the witnesses, eliciting responses from each witness that denied Stahl said Tate caused the bruising. Because of the counsel’s cross-examination, the appeals court again sided with the counsel.

Sufficiency of the evidence

Tate contended the evidence was insufficient to show he acted with malice aforethought, deliberation and premeditation.

The appeals court ruled against Tate, saying the evidence was sufficient to allow a reasonable jury to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that Tate willfully and deliberately shot Stahl with premeditation and malice aforethought.

 

1
Text Only
Top News
  • The case for separate beds

    The other night I slept on a twin bed in the guest room of the house I share with my husband and our two kids.
    It was the best night's sleep I've had in years.

    April 17, 2014

  • Raw oysters spike U.S. rise in bacterial infections, CDC reports

    Raw oysters, so good with hot sauce, increasingly can carry something even more unsettling to the stomach: A bacteria linked to vomiting, diarrhea and pain.

    April 17, 2014

  • Consumer spending on health care jumps as Affordable Care Act takes hold

    Nancy Beigel has known since September that she would need hernia surgery. She couldn't afford it on her $11,000 yearly income until she became eligible for Medicaid in January through President Barack Obama's signature health care law.

    April 17, 2014

  • Astronomers spot most Earth-like planet yet

    Astronomers have discovered what they say is the most Earth-like planet yet detected — a distant, rocky world that's similar in size to our own and exists in the Goldilocks zone where it's not too hot and not too cold for life.

    The find, announced Thursday, excited planet hunters who have been scouring the Milky Way galaxy for years for potentially habitable places outside our solar system.

    April 17, 2014

  • Defend 'Obamacare' unabashedly, some Democrats say

    With enrollments higher than expected, and costs lower, some Democrats say it's time to stop hiding from the president's health care overhaul, even in this year's toughest Senate elections.

    Republicans practically dare Democrats to embrace "Obamacare," the GOP's favorite target in most congressional campaigns. Yet pro-Democratic activists in Alaska are doing just that, and a number of strategists elsewhere hope it will spread.

    April 17, 2014

  • Search for Chicago site for George Lucas museum

    As Yoda might say: A site for a museum you must find.

    Those are the marching orders Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel is giving a dozen civic leaders as the city searches for a potential location for an interactive museum to house filmmaker George Lucas' collection of art and filmmaking memorabilia.

    April 17, 2014

  • Illinois unemployment drops to 5-year-low

    State officials say unemployment in Illinois dropped in March to 8.4 percent. That's its lowest level since 2009.

    April 17, 2014

  • Gaming commission rejects Cedar Rapids casino

    The Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission rejected a proposed $164 million Cedar Rapids casino Thursday, saying it would hurt existing casinos.

    Supporters of the Cedar Crossing Casino development have said it would give an economic boost to Cedar Rapids and the region. They also argued it would be a catalyst for development in an area ravaged by a 2008 flood, create jobs and generate millions for tax revenue and charities.

    April 17, 2014

  • Iowa Senate race suddenly more competitive

    A catchy political ad and a gotcha video have raised Republican hopes of capturing the Senate seat in Iowa, a prospect that would greatly enhance the party's chances of regaining control of the Senate.

    Republicans are adding the seat, held for three decades by retiring Democratic Sen. Tom Harkin, to their list of winnable races in the November midterm elections.

    April 17, 2014

  • Evacuation came too late for many on sinking ferry

    An immediate evacuation order was not issued for the ferry that sank off South Korea's southern coast, likely with scores of people trapped inside, because officers on the bridge were trying to stabilize the vessel after it started to list amid confusion and chaos, a crew member said Thursday.

    Meanwhile, the coast guard said it was investigating whether the ferry's captain was one of the first ones off the sinking ship.

    April 17, 2014

AP Video