The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Top News

October 10, 2013

BREAKING: Expert witness says Walker committed malpractice

DAVENPORT — An expert hired by the city of Clinton testified Thursday that attorney Michael Walker and his law firm committed legal malpractice when they defended the city of Clinton against a federal False Claims Act case filed by former firefighter Timothy Schultheis.

Ronald Clark, who identified himself as an expert in the False Claims Act due to his years and depth of experience with the federal statute, testified Thursday that Walker committed legal malpractice by first accepting the case and subsequently not filing motions to dismiss under two federal rules.  

Walker and his law firm Hopkins and Huebner were retained by the city in September 2009 after the city learned that Schultheis had filed suit in federal court, alleging the city had submitted false claims to Medicare and Medicaid in order to received higher reimbursement rates for ambulance runs.  

The city council voted in August 2010 to settle the suit for $4.5 million to be paid over the course of 10 years to the U.S. Department of Justice and Schultheis, the whistleblower. The city now claims the suit was settled for too much and too soon due to Walker's negligence and is suing him and his firm for legal malpractice and seeking $4.67 million in order to recoup the cost of the settlement as well as other damages.  

The city retained Clark, who is based in D.C., as an expert witness in the legal malpractice case and has paid him around $85,000, Clark testified.  

Accepting the case was Walker's first act of negligence, Clark said. Walker has testified that he had never heard of the False Claims Act before he was retained by the city.   

Clark asserted Walker had serious limitations because he did not know about the "very complicated" False Claims Act and the "unique" defenses the city could have employed. Walker should have turned down the case, sought co-counsel or hired an expert to consult with, Clark testified.  

"He forged ahead with no knowledge," Clark said.  

The subsequent alleged negligence was Walker's failure to assert that Schultheis' complaints were not specific enough and file a motion to dismiss under federal Rule 9(b). While not all circuits of the federal appeals courts agree that whistleblowers need to use specificity, the Eighth Circuit, which Iowa belongs to, does.  Walker also could have filed a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6) on the grounds of an insufficient legal theory, Clark said.

"When you're going to allege fraud in a federal court, you have to do it with specificity so the defendants know what they are being accused of," Clark said.

The complaint Schultheis filed in federal court under seal in September 2008 lacked that specificity, Clark testified. He said the Schultheis complaint lacked specifics about who had committed the alleged fraud, what they had done, where and how.

Clark went paragraph by paragraph through the complaint as the jury followed along, pointing out each area where the complaint was too vague. For instance, Schultheis alleged "all" claims had been submitted falsely. In the Eighth Circuit, the complaint cannot say "all," but must specify which claims, Clark said.  

The vagueness of the complaint, in his opinion, meant that if Walker had filed a motion to dismiss under Rule 9(b), the case would have been dismissed.

Clark also took issue with Schultheis' assertion in his complaint that he had personal knowledge of the claims that had allegedly been false because in his deposition, Schultheis said he had never seen a claim.

"My eyes went large," Clark said. "That alone is enough for this case to be thrown out."  

The list of patients that Schultheis alleged had been submitted as claims contained in the federal complaint were not claims, but ambulance runs, which were not at issue under the False Claims Act, Clark contended.

Clark also asserted Walker should have attacked numerous vague references such as "these false claims," "on numerous occasions" and "managing employees and agents."

Clark's testimony will continue this afternoon.

1
Text Only
Top News
  • Medicaid paid $12M for Illinois dead

    The Illinois Medicaid program paid an estimated $12 million for medical services for people listed as deceased in other state records, according to an internal state government memo.

    The memo dated Friday, which The Associated Press obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request, says the state auditor compared clients enrolled in the Medicaid database last June with state death records dating back to 1970. Auditors identified overpayments for services to roughly 2,900 people after the date of their deaths.

    April 19, 2014

  • Ohio couple married 70 years die 15 hours apart

    A couple who held hands at breakfast every morning even after 70 years of marriage have died 15 hours apart.

    Helen Felumlee, of Nashport, died at 92 on April 12. Her husband, 91-year-old Kenneth Felumlee, died the next morning.

    April 19, 2014

  • Prince reaches agreement with music label

    Prince now owns the rights to the music he recorded on Warner Bros. Records after years of disputes and battles with the record label.

    Warner Bros. announced Friday it had reached an agreement with the pop icon, who was signed to the label from 1978 to the mid-1990s, during which time he released key projects like "Purple Rain," ''1999," ''Diamonds and Pearls" and "Around the World in a Day."

    Financial terms weren't disclosed.

    April 19, 2014

  • Ill. GOP officials who wanted Brady out replaced

    A crop of Republican officials who wanted to oust former Illinois GOP Chairman Pat Brady for his statements supporting same-sex marriage have been replaced in their party positions.

    Illinois Republicans across the state held elections for all 18 state central committee member posts this week, replacing six of the seven officials who signed on to a letter last year to hold a vote on removing Brady as chairman. The seventh person to sign the letter, Mark Shaw of the 10th Congressional District, was re-elected to a four-year term.

    April 19, 2014

  • Iowa gets nearly $72M in yearly tobacco payment

    Iowa received $71 million this week from tobacco companies — its annual share of a 1998 landmark legal settlement in which tobacco companies pay states for smoking-related health care costs.

    The Iowa Attorney General's Office says that since 1999, the state has received more than $960 million in tobacco payments.

    April 19, 2014

  • U of I burn center sees jump in ammonia burns

    The University of Iowa Burn Treatment Center is reporting a higher-than-normal number of patients suffering from anhydrous ammonia burns.

    The center says it has treated five people in the last two weeks. The center's medical personnel say they usually only see one or two cases each year. Official say the high number of patients in such a short amount of time is concerning.

    April 19, 2014

  • Screen shot 2014-04-18 at 4.44.15 PM.png Paint, doodle and sketch: 3 apps for art lovers

    In the absence of a palette of watercolors and a sketchpad, these three apps can fill in as your art supplies of choice.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Smartphone kill switches are coming

    Smartphones need kill switches. It's a relatively easy solution to the pricey (and irritating) problem of smartphone theft. But who would have thought that the big carriers would team up with Apple, Google, Microsoft, Nokia, Samsung and lots of other manufacturers to voluntarily begin adding the technology by July 2015? The cooperative spirit! It makes so much sense!

    April 19, 2014

  • Way of the Cross photo The Way of the Cross By Amy Kent Herald Staff Writer The Way of the Cross

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • John Hood A year after 'chaos'

    It happened two hours after John Hood finished his run. Like many, he thought the loud boom was just the sound of cannons going off, something that shook the ground. It was odd, but Hood — a 1989 Clinton High School graduate — tried to make it logical, associating the noise with another good happening at the Boston Marathon.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

AP Video