The Clinton Herald, Clinton, Iowa

Top News

February 17, 2014

Judge rules against firefighter's discrimination claim

CLINTON — A Clinton County District Court judge has ruled against a female Clinton firefighter who claimed her rights were violated when superiors refused to put her on light duty while she was pregnant.

"The Court finds that the City's policy does not infringe on Mrs. (Karen) McQuistion's fundamental right to procreate," Clinton County District Court Judge Henry Latham wrote in the 13-page judgment, which was filed late last week.

Serving with the fire department since January 2001, McQuistion became aware that she was pregnant on May 9, 2011. According to the court ruling, she notified her battalion chief, Joel Atkinson, of her pregnancy, requesting to be put on light duty. This includes inspections, water hydrant checks, fire prevention, duties, training assignments and duties with the juvenile fire offender program.

In June 2011, then-Fire Chief Mark Regenwether, former City Attorney Jeffrey Farwell and former City Administrator Jeffrey Horne met to discuss her pregnancy and rejected her request for light duty work. McQuistion stopped working on Sept. 29, 2011 and returned to work on March 14, 2012, with the same pay and benefits she had previously received. She filed her lawsuit on March 28, 2012.

In his ruling, Latham considered pregnancy discrimination under the Iowa Civil Rights Acts, which requires pregnant employees to be considered as having "temporary disabilities" and that the same terms and conditions are applied as for other temporary disabilities. McQuistion's lawsuit had claimed that the fire department offers light duty to other firefighters with disabilities. However, Latham stated in his ruling that this does not apply to the plaintiff.

"The conditions of the City's policy are clear. If an employee is disabled on the job, the City must provide her with light duty work. If an employee is disabled off the job, the City is not required to provide her light duty work," Latham stated. "McQuistion's disability was acquired off the job."

McQuistion's lawsuit also referenced two Clinton police women who were given light duty during their pregnancies. However, Latham determined McQuistion is not "similarly situated" to the pregnant police officers because police and firefighters fall under different collective bargaining agreements. Since these were the only two city employees that McQuistion had referenced to prove different treatment from the city, Latham denied her equal protection argument.

In her lawsuit, McQuistion argued that the city's policy infringed upon her fundamental right to procreate. Latham disagreed with her and found she was in fact arguing her employer was obligated to provide her with certain advantages that she would not be normally provided "to mitigate the natural disadvantages that come with pregnancy."

"That is not the law," Latham wrote. "If the city had implemented its policy in order to explicitly or implicitly punish female employees for choosing to have children, that policy would infringe on the fundamental right to procreate. In the present case, Mrs. McQuistion has not provided evidence of Defendant's motive to do so."

Attempts to reach McQuistion and her attorney Roxanne Conlin for comment were unsuccessful.

1
Text Only
Top News
  • portraitoflotte.jpg VIDEO: From infant to teen in four minutes

    Dutch filmmaker Frans Hofmeester’s time lapse video of his daughter, Lotte — created by filming her every week from her birth until she turned 14 — has become a viral sensation.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • All 'View' co-hosts will salute Barbara Walters

    ABC's "The View" will gather all 11 past and present co-hosts to salute Barbara Walters as she retires from daily television.

    The network said Wednesday the first-ever reunion will air live on the May 15 episode of "The View," the day before Walters says goodbye as series co-host.

    April 16, 2014

  • Regents considering Branstad order on settlements

    More than three weeks later, the Iowa Board of Regents is still figuring out how to comply with Gov. Terry Branstad's order to post employee settlement agreements online.

    In an executive order on March 24, Branstad ordered his administration and the regents to post all legal agreements that resolve employment disputes on websites that are easily accessible to the public.

    April 16, 2014

  • Victimized by the 'marriage penalty'

    In a few short months, I'll pass the milestone that every little girl dreams of: the day she swears - before family and God, in sickness and in health, all in the name of love - that she's willing to pay a much higher tax rate.

    April 16, 2014

  • 10 Things to Know for Today

    Your daily look at late-breaking news, upcoming events and the stories that will be talked about today:

    April 16, 2014

  • Police: GPS helped solve, didn't deter Calif. killings SANTA ANA, Calif. (AP) -- GPS technology helped police link two convicted sex offenders to the rapes and killings of at least four women in California, but the mother of one victim said Tuesday that the monitoring system should have done more to prev

    April 16, 2014

  • Smithsonian Tyrannosaurus Rex-15 [Duplicate] T. rex gets new home in Smithsonian WASHINGTON -- More than 100 years after dinosaurs were first displayed on the National Mall, T. rex -- the king -- is joining the Smithsonian collection after a 2,000-mile journey from Montana. Paleontologists and curators unveiled parts of a nearly

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Medical Marijuana [Duplicate] Medical pot measure could boost Florida Democrats MIAMI -- Tied to an unpopular president and his signature health care law, Democrats in the nation's largest swing state see medical marijuana as a potential antidote to political malaise in this year's midterm elections. Party operatives are pushing

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Russia tests Obama's ability to stop its advances WASHINGTON -- With the White House asserting that Russia is stoking instability in eastern Ukraine, President Barack Obama is once again faced with the complicated reality of following through on his tough warnings against overseas provocations. Obam

    April 16, 2014

  • City considers upsizing storm sewer capacity CAMANCHE -- Residential development is a key component to the fortitude of Camanche, according to city leaders so they are taking the steps necessary to keep it an appealing location for future investors. To do so, those leaders are looking to up siz

    April 16, 2014

AP Video