That’s a term we’ve heard several times during the past few months as the Clinton Humane Society and the Clinton City Council continue to be at a stalemate over whether the city is going to continue to pay the society to subsidize its operations.
The Humane Society during the past few months has been seeking $120,000 for the next year, nearly double the $65,000 it now receives from the city. The reasons are many and varied as to why the Humane Society says it needs that increase — rising costs, declines in fund-raising and trusts that no longer exist to produce revenue. This year was similar to 2011’s budget discussion in that there were heavy-handed discussions about how the society must have an increase.
While an agreement was reached that time around, this time has been different.
It wasn’t that long ago when the Internal Operations Committee sat down with Humane Society leaders to further discuss what would happen if the city did not comply with the request. Humane Society officials were adamant at the December meeting if no contract was in place with the city by Feb. 1, the date of the contract’s expiration, the society would not be willing to work with the city. The society would be ready to move on, they said, and would not take animals on a month-by-month basis as was suggested by Clinton Police Chief Brian Guy.
The council members at that meeting said there needed to be a Plan B ready in case no agreement was reached with the Humane Society, and that more discussion was needed to get an alternative plan ready because the city did not have the money to cover the hike.
When that meeting broke up, it appeared that city officials knew there would have to be an alternate plan in the works as the Humane Society leaders were ready to walk away from the table.
So how can it be that here we are, mere weeks later, in such a quandary?
Well, it continued when the council ultimately decided to put the agreement in place with the Humane Society, on their terms, while an ad hoc committee would study an alternate method to save money on the contract with society officials. But then a veto by Mayor Mark Vulich 13 days later put those approvals on ice. The council could have overturned the vetoes, but failed to do so last week. Also failing was an agreement to pay a $40,000 subsidy to All Pets to provide services for the city.
Because there is no agreement with the Humane Society, Clinton animals are no longer being received there. All Pets was receiving dogs as detailed under the law, but with no agreement and then the standing vetoes, biting dogs now are being transported to Scott County's humane society.
It has been confusing, to say the least.
But did it have to be?
Because the Humane Society threw all its cards on the table and its leaders said they needed $120,000 or they were going to walk, they should not be surprised, as they were, when they no longer had a contract — especially when they said they wouldn’t help out after Feb. 1.
There was a light at the end of the tunnel when the council approved 5-2 to set up the tentative agreement.
That is, until the mayor vetoed it and essentially stopped any services from being provided to the city by the Humane Society.
While many say that action was ill-timed, we agree with it.
We say that because under state law, the city only has to take care of bite cases, vicious dogs and dogs running at large. We have no extra money to take care of the pets and to serve as an adoption agency. That should be done by a nonprofit organization operating independently from the city. We believe now is the time for such a group to take over the reins, whether it be the current Humane Society, which has the option of becoming a no kill shelter and tapping donations and grants from people and organizations who support that mission, or a new group that is able to obtain donations.
We also believe that our Humane Society has lost a lot of support because of internal strife over the last six to seven years and that people were fed up with seeing money go out the door for lawsuits.
All those factors lead us to believe that the council is doing the right thing by going out for proposal for animal control services.
It would have been nice if the city's plan B would have been in place, gained council approval and could have gone into effect sooner to limit confusion, but in the end, not allowing the city to be strong armed by the Humane Society is the right thing to do.
- Top News
- Students build toward learning CLINTON -- Building robots and small cities out of Legos is more than just a game for students at Camanche Elementary School and River Bend Middle School. It is a chance to win a national championship. The For Inspiration and Recognition of Science a
- Christmas in the Canyon tradition continues this weekend FULTON, Ill. -- Christmas is in the air, and in the canyon in Fulton, as the annual Christmas in the Canyon celebration kicks off the holiday season on Saturday. Originally started by Harold and Thelma Wierenga, the Christmas in the Canyon tradition
- Library bake sale will benefit Camanche library CAMANCHE -- The annual Friends of the Library bake sale will take place from 8 a.m. to 12 p.m. Saturday at Clinton National Bank in Camanche and members of the Camanche Public Library are excited to welcome the community once again. For more than 10
Council delays alcohol rules talks
CLINTON -- City officials are kicking the proverbial beer can down the road. During a Rules and Regulations Committee meeting Tuesday, members debated altering the percentage of sales stemming from items other than alcohol and making other changes
- Camanche city hall plans proceed CAMANCHE -- All the appropriate steps have been taken by the Camanche City Council to acquire a new building for city hall, but now comes the difficult part of remodeling and furnishing the space. Several City Council and Council-elect members met Tu
- Four help rebuild New Orleans CLINTON -- Four Clinton residents representing the Sisters of St. Francis traveled to New Orleans in November to help the survivors of Hurricane Katrina rebuild. Although eight years have passed since the storm put most of New Orleans under water, t
- Catholic radio station celebrates 10 years CLINTON -- For 10 years, the KXJX Catholic Radio station in Clinton has delivered a message of faith to its listeners, and on Sunday the station will celebrate those 10 years at the Feast of the Immaculate Conception. The local radio station, which
- Businesses make it to next level of contest CLINTON -- Two downtown Clinton businesses are moving on to the next level of a regional contest in hopes of receiving a $5,000 grant. Déjà Vu Furniture and the Painted Rooster are among eight Quad-City area businesses that will pitch their business
- Contest draws attention to healthy living CLINTON -- "Let's live healthy, Clinton!" is a new campaign slogan created to motivate the city of Clinton and surrounding areas to get up, get out and get active. Driven by Mercy Medical Center and Genesis Health Systems, the "Let's Live Healthy, Cl
Couple appeals eminent domain compensation decision
CLINTON — The property owners whose land the city is taking through eminent domain to expand Eagle Point Park have filed an appeal.
- More Top News Headlines